Welcome to Old Mill Pizzeria
Old Mill Pizzeria, nestled at 5784 US-209 in Sciota, PA, has been a beloved destination for nearly 25 years, known for its exceptional food and warm, welcoming staff. With a vibrant and clean atmosphere, it offers a large menu featuring specialty pizzas, calzones, and more, ensuring there's something for everyone. Customers rave about the generous portions and reasonable prices, making it a great choice for families and gatherings. Whether dining in or taking out, each dish, like the praised chicken bacon ranch stuffed pizza, delivers memorable flavors that delight the palate. Old Mill Pizzeria is truly a gem in the community.
Old Mill Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings
Great food, friendly staff, and the pizza has been the best around for nearly 25 years.
Clean, bright pizzeria. Large menu selection, specialty pizzas and much more than pizza. Friendly, smiling staff. Food is delicious, portions are large, and prices are reasonable. This was my first visit, and I'll be going back!
Our family rented the side room they have for private parties. We were very pleased with the quality of the food, timeliness of the food preparation and the service provided. Highly recommend if you need space for about 35 people.
I’ve been eating here all my life for 30 years, best place in town the owner is a great guy and weather you dine in or carry out the food is always always ALWAYS great, got a combo calzone tonight with an order of knots and it was out of this world.
Had a house full of kids. Kids love pizza...any kind of pizza. The basic plain, Pepperoni, and meat lovers were fantastic! But let me tell you about the pie ordered for the adults.... CBR (chicken bacon ranch) in a stuffed pizza. How was it? they nailed it. Chiken was tender, bacon was flavorful, and the amount of cheese was perfect. Thanks to Old Mill Pizza for making this one off pizza!
The Old Mill Pizza is Family owned, very hard working and it shows they cook with love. Service is impeccable. I stopped in and noticed the ownership/management & staff had completely changed for the best I've ever seen here. It appeared to be a family working together- mother/father/daughter combination, like how pizza places used to be growing up. They spoke kindly to customers as well as to each other. They took my order and brought my food out to me at the table. Everyone seemed happy and very pleasant, what a great atmosphere they've created. They did this for everyone, at booths or in dining area. Everything looks so cleaned up and brighter inside. You could eat off the floor and sink top in the bathroom & smelled fresh like fruit. A definite change. Let's talk about the food now...It was lunchtime, so I ordered 2 plain slices and a side of garlic knots to go. It was tempting to order the Sicilian slices as they looked so pretty and fresh on the countertop. I hadn't seen true New York style Sicilian look that good around here for a while. The slices were cut from a freshly made pie and looked delicious and were served hot. Not sitting around in a case on the countertop for hours like other places I've been to locally. The sauce was thick and flavorful and not Watered down. The crust wasn't too thick & wasn't too thin, just right. Cheese was perfect not too much, not too little. All the spices were filled, fresh and containers were all clean. Plenty of napkins on every table top. The woman whom took my order was very polite and offered plenty of time to look over the menu which was very professional looking, with large enough writing and a beautiful display of colors and pics to persuade me to want to try everything. The prices were average reasonable and there were plenty of choices for everyone in your family, from salads, pizzas, entrees, sides and lots more. Don't worry if your loyal to a brand of drink Pepsi or coke etc. They have a soda fountain and a cooler full of bottled sodas cans and other soft drinks to go or stay. Plenty of real drinking straws too! I give it 2 yummy thumbs up as it's now added to my regular route of food stops now. Don't hesitate to dine in or call ahead as I saw them answering the phone on the first ring, unlike past owners, whom would let it ring off the hook! It's refreshing to see a family run style pizza place still exists locally. I will update this post with more photos as I will definitely visit again and again in the future. Thank you for all your hard work and kindness it shows and is appreciated.
Our go to for 30 years. Excellent food. Our favorite place,pizza..Greek salad ...steak wraps are all excellent. Pasta dishes come with salad and bread. Owner on site and is cooking and overseeing every time we’re in. Never had a bad meal. Friday and Saturday place is full so order accordingly. Chicken Alfredo is enough for two hungry people and excellent. We love this place.
This place has hands down the BEST grandmas pizza. The place is clean and sanitary. Service is also great, they don't take long with the food. 10/10 reccomend.
Location
-
5784 US-209, Sciota, PA 18354, United States Hotline: +1 570-992-7009
Welcome to Old Mill Pizzeria, a cherished culinary destination located at 5784 US-209 in the charming town of Sciota, Pennsylvania. Known for its inviting atmosphere and dedicated service, Old Mill has been a staple in the community for nearly 25 years, consistently delighting customers with its exceptional pizza and diverse menu offerings.
From the moment you step through the doors, the bright and clean surroundings create a welcoming environment. As one visitor, Rhonda McCloughan, noted, the friendly and smiling staff enhances the dining experience, making it not just a meal, but a cherished moment. The expansive menu offers much more than just pizza. It features an array of specialty pizzas that cater to varied tastes, ensuring that there's something for everyone – from traditional flavors to creative concoctions like the CBR, a stuffed pizza filled with chicken, bacon, and ranch that has garnered rave reviews.
For families, Old Mill Pizzeria stands as a favorite choice, praised for its generous portions and reasonable prices. Scott and Jessica Holmes found the classic pepperoni and meat lovers' pizzas to be a hit with their kids, while the adult crowd enjoyed an unforgettable CBR pizza, perfectly crafted with tender chicken and flavorful bacon. It’s clear that Old Mill not only meets but exceeds expectations.
Moreover, the venue's private dining space is perfect for gatherings, as George Buynak discovered. Renting out the side room for family celebrations resulted in timely service and quality food that delighted guests. This flexibility solidifies Old Mill’s position not just as a pizzeria but as a versatile dining option in the area.
Locals like Buck from Buck’s Bucks & Outdoor Adventures have been enjoying Old Mill's offerings for over three decades, and their legacy of great food continues to thrive. Whether you choose to dine in or carry out, the combination of delectable calzones and signature garlic knots showcases the culinary passion behind each dish.
Next time you find yourself in Sciota, visit Old Mill Pizzeria. With a rich history of dedication and a menu that continues to impress, it's a place where delicious food and warm service come together to create memorable dining experiences.