Old Mill Pizzeria Menu
Welcome to Old Mill Pizzeria, a cherished establishment located in Sciota, PA, known for its warm atmosphere and delightful menu. Since its inception nearly 25 years ago, this pizzeria has garnered a loyal following, praised for its exceptional pizza and friendly service. Guests rave about the diverse menu, which offers not only classic pizzas but also innovative specialty options, like the tantalizing CBR stuffed pizza, a favorite among adults.
- Friendly Environment: Visitors appreciate the cheerful staff and clean, inviting space.
- Versatile Menu: From large family portions to private party rentals, there’s something for everyone.
- Quality and Flavor: Regulars testify that whether dining in or taking out, the food consistently delights.
Old Mill Pizzeria is a perfect destination for casual dining or special gatherings. Come experience why this gem has delighted palates for decades!
Pizza
Specialty Pizza
Pizza by the Slice
Calzones
Stromboli
Appetizers & Sides
Salads
Hot Pita-Wiches
Baskets
Hot Hoagies
Cold Hoagies
Cold Grinders
Wraps
Burgers
Gyro
Specialty Dinners
Kids Menu
Beverages
Lunch Specials
Catering Pick Up
Desserts
Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
US$25.95
German Pizza
White Pizza
Chicken Bruschetta Pizza
US$26.95
Veggie Pizza
Hawaiian Pizza
Mexican Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Grandma Square Pizza
US$25.95
The Old Mill Combo Special Pizza
Specialty Pizza
Pizza by the Slice
Cheese Pizza Slice
US$3.75
1. Ham & Pepperoni Calzone
US$16.95
2. Sausage Calzone
US$16.95
3. Ham, Pepperoni, Sausage Calzone
US$16.95
4. All Cheese Calzone
US$13.00
5. Combo Calzone
US$17.95
6. Veggie Calzone
US$17.95
7. Fresh Chicken Calzone
US$17.95
Calzones
Stromboli
Classic Stromboli
Sausage Roll
US$9.95
French Fries
US$5.70
Cheese Fries
US$6.70
Onion Rings
US$5.70
Pierogies
US$5.70
Side Of Meatballs
US$9.70
Side Of Sausage
US$9.70
Breaded Mushrooms
US$5.70
Mozzarella Sticks
US$6.70
Garlic Cheese Bread
US$8.70
Garlic Knots
US$8.95
Breadsticks
US$7.70
Garlic Bread
US$6.70
Wings
US$16.70
Boneless Wings
US$15.70
Appetizers & Sides
Salads
Tossed Salad
Antipasto Salad
US$13.70
Grilled Chicken Salad
Chef Salad
US$13.70
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
Famous Greek Salad
Ham Sandwich
US$10.70
Capicola Sandwich
US$10.70
Salami Sandwich
US$10.70
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
US$10.70
Combination Sandwich
US$10.70
Turkey Bacon Twist Sandwich
US$10.70
Turkey Sandwich
US$10.70
Cheese Sandwich
US$10.70
Hot Pita-Wiches
Baskets
Crispy Chicken Basket
US$15.70
Chicken Fingers Basket
US$15.70
Breaded Shrimp Basket
US$15.70
Pizza Burger
US$12.70
Veal Parmigiana Hoagie
US$12.70
Chicken Hoagie
US$12.70
Chicken Parmigiana Hoagie
US$12.70
Eggplant Parmigiana Hoagie
US$12.70
Sausage Hoagie
US$12.70
Sausage Parmigiana Hoagie
US$12.70
Meatball Parmigiana Hoagie
US$12.70
BBQ Chicken Sandwich
US$12.70
BBQ Philly Steak Sandwich
US$12.70
Steak Sandwich
US$10.70
Steak Sandwich With Everything
US$12.70
Cheesesteak Sandwich
US$10.70
Cheesesteak Sandwich With Everything
US$12.70
Chicken Cheesesteak Sandwich
US$10.70
Chicken Cheesesteak Sandwich With Everything
US$12.70
Hot Hoagies
Cold Hoagies
Ham Hoagie
US$10.70
Salami Hoagie
US$10.70
Capicola Hoagie
US$10.70
Cheese Hoagie
US$10.70
Turkey Hoagie
US$12.70
BLT Hoagie
US$12.70
Grilled Chicken Hoagie
US$12.70
Tuna Hoagie
US$12.70
Italian Hoagie
US$12.70
Ham Grinder
US$12.45
Salami Grinder
US$12.45
Capicola Grinder
US$12.45
Cheese Grinder
US$12.45
Turkey Grinder
US$14.45
BLT Grinder
US$14.45
Grilled Chicken Grinder
US$14.45
Tuna Grinder
US$14.45
Italian Grinder
US$14.45
Cold Grinders
Wraps
Grilled Chicken Wrap
US$10.70
Crispy Chicken Wrap
US$10.70
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
US$10.70
Chicken Steak Wrap
US$10.70
Steak Wrap
US$10.70
BBQ Chicken Wrap
US$10.70
Tuna Wrap
US$10.70
Hamburger
US$9.70
Cheeseburger
US$10.70
California Burger
US$12.70
California Cheeseburger
US$12.70
Burgers
Gyro
Gyro Sandwich
US$10.70
Gyro Platter
US$14.70
Spaghetti With Marinara Sauce
US$10.95
Spaghetti With Meat Sauce
US$15.95
Spaghetti With Meatballs
US$17.95
Baked Ziti
US$15.95
Cheese Ravioli
US$17.95
Chicken Parmigiana
US$20.95
Veal Parmigiana
US$20.95
Eggplant Parmigiana
US$20.95
Meat Lasagna
US$17.95
Chicken Alfredo
US$24.95
Shrimp Alfredo
US$25.95
Fettuccine Alfredo
US$19.95
Penne Alfredo
US$19.95
Penne Alla Vodka
US$19.95
Chicken Marsala
US$24.95
Specialty Dinners
Kids Menu
Kid's Chicken Fingers & Fries
US$9.70
Kid's Spaghetti
US$9.70
Kid's Ravioli
US$9.70
Kid's Lasagna
US$9.70
Kid's Ziti
US$9.70
Soda
Iced Tea
Milk
Coffee
US$3.25
Beverages
Lunch Specials
1. Small Greek Salad & Plain Pizza Slice Lunch Special
US$8.70
2. Hamburger & Fries Lunch Special
US$12.70
4. Any Pita Bread Sandwich & Fries Lunch Special
US$14.70
5. Gyro Sandwich & Fries Lunch Special
US$14.70
6. Any Cold Hoagie & Fries Lunch Special
US$14.70
7. Meatball Parm Sandwich & Fries Lunch Special
US$14.70
8. BLT Sandwich & Fries Lunch Special
US$14.70
9. Two Plain Pizza Slices & Small Drink Lunch Special
US$7.70
10. Sausage Roll & Small Drink Lunch Special
US$9.70
11. Chicken Parm Sandwich & Fries Lunch Special
US$14.70
12. Chicken Cheesesteak Sandwich & Fries Lunch Special
US$14.70
3. Cheesesteak Sandwich & Fries Lunch Special
US$14.70
Garlic Knots Catering
Chicken Ala Vodka Catering
Lasagna Catering
Ravioli Catering
Baked Ziti Catering
Penne Broccoli & Olive Oil Catering
Tortellini Marinara Catering
Eggplant Rollatini Catering
Penne Alla Vodka Catering
Chicken Parmigiana Catering
Chicken Marsala Catering
Sausage, Peppers & Onions Catering
Meatballs Marinara Catering
Swedish Meatballs Catering
Chicken Fingers Catering
Greek Salad Catering
Caesar Salad Catering
Tossed Salad Catering
Catering Pick Up
Desserts
Ice Cream
US$7.00
Milkshake
Cannoli
US$6.00